Risky Business

10-25-2020Fr. John LettersFr. John Bonavitacola

Dear Friends,

It’s Election time again and that means for us in AZ: Ballot Propositions. Arizona law makes it rather easy to get a Proposition on the Ballot for Voter approval/disapproval but at the same time makes it very difficult to change, refine or tweak Voter Approved Ballot Propositions. If there are unintended consequences or problems with a Voter Approved Proposition it is a real heavy lift for the legislature to make any changes, requiring a 75% majority in both Houses.

Case in point Proposition 207, not the current Proposition on the Ballot but Prop 207 that was Voter approved in 2006. That Proposition greatly restricted municipalities ability to change zoning requirements to prevent or restrict private development. For us in Tempe, this is now becoming a challenge.

READ MORE

Tied Up in Moral Knots

10-18-2020Fr. John LettersFr. John Bonavitacola

Dear Friends,

G.K Chesterton once famously advised against removing what may look like a needless fence until you know why it was put there in the first place. Case in point is the argument over conscience rights or conscientious objection. This long held moral principle states that a person has a right to refuse, based on their sincerely held beliefs to perform or participate in certain actions that they deem morally repugnant, harmful or a violation of their conscience. The classic example is fighting in a war.

More recently the issue of conscience rights has surfaced in regards to medical providers who refuse to participate in certain non-therapeutic medical procedures that they deem immoral or harmful actions such as abortion or sex reassignment surgery. On the other side the argument is that there is no individual right to refuse to provide a procedure when requested by a patient. Seems like they are willing to remove a fence without considering the implications.

READ MORE

NO on Prop 207

10-11-2020Fr. John LettersFr. John Bonavitacola

Dear Friends,

The Catholic Bishops of Arizona have taken a position against Prop 207 (The legalization of recreational use marijuana and hashish in AZ). They ask us as Catholics and faithful citizens to consider the harmful effects that passage of Prop 207 would bring to our young people and our communities in general. The harm is not theoretical or hypothetical but is based on the experience of US states that have legalized recreational marijuana as well as the increased use of marijuana in AZ since the legalization of medical marijuana.

READ MORE

Same Church? Different Pew?

10-04-2020Fr. John LettersFr. John Bonavitacola

Dear Friends,

ACB had been nominated to fill the seat occupied by the late RBG. There are two things I find curious about this nomination. If Judge Barrett is seated on the Court, then six of the nine Justices will be Catholic (Roberts, Thomas, Alito, Kavanaugh, Sotomayor). Considering that Catholics make up about a little less than a quarter of the population of the US that would mean that Catholics are way overrepresented on the High Court. How did that happen? Luck of the draw? Were they all just in the right place at the right time? Social Darwinism? Catholic Karma? Is the Pope giving orders to the various Presidents? Or do non-Catholic Presidents have a thing for Catholic justices? Are Catholics just better at jurisprudence than everyone else?

READ MORE